Robert Willoughby
Mr. Willoughby is an experienced trial attorney who, since joining Hassard Bonnington in 1997, has dedicated his legal career to the representation of health care providers in a variety of contexts, primarily the defense of medical negligence lawsuits alleging catastrophic injuries or alleged wrongful death. Mr. Willoughby is also very experienced in handling matters before the California Medical Board and California Nursing Board, premises liability claims, and hospital staff issues.
A native San Franciscan, Mr. Willoughby moved to Marin County with his family at the age of 7. While in the 8th grade at Ross School, he won several national awards and commendations for rescuing two elderly residents from a burning home near the school. After graduating high school from The Branson School, Mr. Willoughby attended the University of California Berkeley, where he double majored in Political Science and Mass Communications.
The son of a respected journalist and press secretary, Mr. Willoughby initially worked in local and national politics for four years before deciding to attend law school at the University of San Francisco School of Law. While at USF Law, he won a Best Oral Argument award and served as a Judicial Extern to Justice Timothy A. Reardon at the California Court of Appeal.
Since joining Hassard Bonnington out of law school in 1997, Mr. Willoughby has always considered it a great honor and privilege to represent the Bay Area’s finest medical providers. He has been a partner of the firm since 2006.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/15602/15602112ad7733032f8a7afab5dab99ce2deb742" alt=""
HASSARD BONNINGTON LLP, San Francisco, CA
Partner, 2006-Present; Associate, 1997-2006
- April 2018, Medical Negligence. Defense trial verdict on behalf of university hospital in a lawsuit alleging failure to timely diagnose and treat compartment syndrome, resulting in permanent neurologic injuries.
- February 2018, Medical Negligence and Wrongful Death. Defense trial verdict on behalf of neurologist and university hospital in four-week trial involving $41.18 million in claimed damages based on an alleged violation of Health & Safety Code §103900.
- October 2015, Medical Board Hearing and Appeal in Physician’s Favor. Represented physician at trial and appeal following Medical Board’s denial of licensure, resulting in issuance of medical license with no conditions.
- September 2013, Medical Negligence, Dismissal of all Claims at Trial. Obtained dismissal of all claims against internal medicine physician at trial involving an alleged violation of Health & Safety Code §102800.
- June 2011, Medical Negligence. Defense trial verdict on behalf of pulmonologist following trial involving an alleged failure to monitor a patient (also a physician) following prescription of medication for tuberculosis.
- February 2006, Medical Negligence and Wrongful Death. Defense trial verdict on behalf of a university hospital and cardiologist following trial involving a patient’s death during a cardiac stenting procedure.
EH v. UC Regents - Gender Affirming Care to Minor: Plaintiff, father of the youth, sued alleging the child was provided with a hormonal implant without his consent. Through two motions to dismiss in federal court, all of plaintiff's claims were eliminated. The appeal is pending. Lead attorney handling all aspects of case and coordinating strategy with co-defendants -2024.
QB v. SBH - Birth Injury with Brain Injuries Case: Patient, a twin, alleged significant birth injuries due to a prolapsed umbilical cord. Strategic low value settlement was achieved at mediation. Co-defendant proceeded to trial with large 8-figure verdict. Lead attorney handling all aspects of case and coordinating strategy with co-defendants through resolution -2024.
JD v. MESR - Alleged Sexual Assault at Massage Therapy Franchise: Patient alleged she was assaulted at a massage clinic. Discovery revealed no therapist matched the description of the alleged assailant and the case was dismissed for a nominal amount - Lead attorney handling all aspects of case through resolution - 2024.
MP v. SH - Alleged Failure to Diagnose Bladder Cancer: Plaintiff alleged defendants failed to properly diagnose a kidney cyst as renal cell carcinoma. With a motion for summary judgment pending, plaintiffs agreed to dismiss SH for a waiver of costs at mediation. Lead attorney handling all aspects of case through dismissal - 2023.
XC v. The Regents - Alleged Breach of Contract and Conversion of IVF Embryos: Plaintiff alleged The Regents wrongfully retained her embryos and refused to transfer them to another facility. Plaintiff's case was dismissed on demurrer. Following a successful appeal, plaintiff's case was again dismissed following a motion for terminating sanctions. Lead attorney handling all aspects of case through dismissal - 2023.
MM v. The Regents – Premises Liability/Design Defect: Patient alleged she slipped and fell while a patient on the maternity ward due to a defective design. Complex motion for summary judgment granted based on governmental immunities – 2021
PL v. The Regents – Alleged Delay in Transfer of Stroke Patient: Patient was taken to a local hospital for signs of a stroke. The case was filed in federal court including allegations of violation of EMTALA, medical malpractice, NIED, dependent adult abuse, wrongful death and intentional misconduct. Contested motion to dismiss was granted in its entirety, ending the case. Lead attorney handling all aspects of case through dismissal – 2021.
KRB v. SHC – Wrongful Life/Wrongful Birth Case: Plaintiffs alleged negligent genetic counseling failed to identify that plaintiff child’s parents were both sickle cell anemia carriers. Plaintiff child was born with sickle cell anemia. Discovery revealed plaintiff mother’s knowledge of her status as a carrier of sickle cell anemia. Thereafter, the case resolved for nuisance value. Lead attorney handling all aspects of case through resolution – 2020.
AS v. SH - Wrongful Life/Wrongful Birth Case: Plaintiff alleged defendant lab failed to identify the genetic marker for cystic fibrosis during prenatal testing, resulting in the birth of a child with severe cystic fibrosis. Plaintiff required very costly medication for life, had significant care needs and a relatively long life expectancy given advances in treatment for cystic fibrosis. Initial demand for $50 million. Experts were disclosed, key depositions taken and case was resolved for an amount in the low seven figures, a significant victory for the defense. Lead attorney handling all aspects of case through resolution – 2020.
CM v. SH - Wrongful Death – Failure to Diagnose Malaria: Plaintiff alleged defendant hospital and physician failed to diagnose malaria, leading to his discharge from the emergency department and death. Plaintiff sought and obtained a significant settlement from the treating emergency physician and proceeded with the case against the hospital. Days before trial, the case settled for nuisance value. Lead attorney handling all aspects of case through resolution – 2019.
GS v. SH - Severely Brain-Injured Child: Plaintiff mom and plaintiff child alleged medical negligence related to care and treatment plaintiff child received in the NICU. Plaintiff child had a PICC line placed for nutrition and medication administration. The PICC line migrated and caused a pericardial effusion. Plaintiff child’s heart stopped and he underwent a prolonged resuscitation until the pericardial effusion was identified and tapped. Plaintiff mom was brought up to the NICU while the code was in process and brought an NIED claim. The NIED claim was eliminated with a motion for summary adjudication. The plaintiff child had profound neurological injuries but also a significantly long life expectancy. A favorable settlement was reached following development of causation arguments related to placental pathology. Lead attorney handling all aspects of case through resolution – 2019.
EG v. The Regents: Plaintiff alleged negligent attempted placement of an epidural catheter prior to hernia surgery, leading to an epidural hematoma and lower extremity paralysis. Plaintiff was a high wage earner with no ability to work and a significant remaining work-life expectancy. Prior to trial, the case was presented to two mock juries, with opening statements, a few witness presentations and closing arguments presented to the mock juries. Expert depositions were underway when plaintiff passed away from unrelated causes. Co-lead attorney handling causation and damages experts – 2018.
- University of San Francisco School of Law, J.D., 1996
- University of California, Berkeley, B.A. (Double Major, Political Science and Mass Communications), 1988
- The Branson School, 1983
Hassard Bonnington LLP
111 Pine Street, Suite 1530
San Francisco CA 94111
Main (415) 288-9800
Direct (415) 690-2744